A new round of green subsidies goes to some familiar names.
Updated Oct. 25, 2013 7:13 p.m. ET
Discretionary spending may be capped, but
times are still flush for one group of federal clients—green energy
companies. In September as the government headed toward a shutdown, the
Department of Energy pushed out the door another $66 million in
green-energy subsidies to 33 companies and research facilities.
Some
$34 million in grants were earmarked for "advanced liquid fuels" that
are derived from gases, such as methane. Nearly 30% of those
funds—almost $9.5 million—went to three companies, LanzaTech, Greenlight
Biosciences and Coskata. What all three also have in common is
investment by Khosla Ventures, the venture capital firm run by
Vinod Khosla.
The Silicon Valley investor has a knack for getting taxpayers to
aid his companies.
Vinod Khosla, founder of Khosla Ventures
Reuters
Consider LanzaTech, which was founded
in New Zealand and has offices in Illinois. In 2011, the Department of
Energy announced that LanzaTech was one of three firms awarded $4
million each in grants to produce biofuels. The company also received a
$3 million Federal Aviation Administration contract to work on
"alternative" aviation fuel. LanzaTech's recent grant was for another $4
million and was the second largest of the 33 awards that the Energy
Department announced. (The largest, $4.5 million, went to Greenlight,
another Khosla-funded company.)
In
January, LanzaTech announced it was buying a cellulosic ethanol refinery
in Soperton, Georgia, in a foreclosure auction for $5.1 million. The
refinery owner, Range Fuels, was forced to liquidate despite being
awarded a $76 million grant from the Energy Department in 2007 (it
ultimately received $46 million) and a $80 million loan from the
Department of Agriculture (it received about $40 million and repaid $2
million).
The state of Georgia also provided money.
You
won't be shocked to learn that Khosla Ventures was a major investor in
Range Fuels. The federal government lost more than $80 million on Range
Fuels, and it is now investing another $4 million in a company buying
assets of that previous failure. Mr. Khosla's venture company gets help
coming and going.
These recent federal
grants were made a few months after Mr. Khosla hosted a fundraiser in
June at his California home for the Democratic Senatorial Campaign
Committee. Price of admission: $32,400.
President
Obama
attended, as did Democratic Senators
Michael Bennet
(Colorado),
Maria Cantwell
(Washington) and
Amy Klobuchar
(Minnesota).
A few days after
the Energy Department announced its September grants, LanzaTech welcomed
former Obama campaign director
Jim Messina
to its board of directors. When not dispensing his vast technical
expertise about "advanced liquid fuels," Mr. Messina runs Organizing
for America, which is Mr. Obama's vehicle for advanced liquid politics.
Mr.
Khosla tells us politics was not involved in the grants and that he
hasn't visited the Energy or Agriculture departments or "talked to
anyone in those organizations this year." He says he was only recently
made aware of the LanzaTech and Coskata grants, and that GreenLight had
applied for a grant before "we even decided to invest."
He
adds that these are "research grants" made through the Energy
Department's ARPA-E program and are "not material compared to the
commercial fundraising" of these companies. He nonetheless argues that
ARPA-E funding "has been incredibly effective, and without it this sort
of research would die."
LanzaTech CEO
Jennifer Holmgren
says politics played no part in her company's grant. She says
that such government grants allow companies to leverage their
infrastructure to embark on "high-risk, long-term" projects that Wall
Street or private investors wouldn't necessarily fund.
The
Energy Department claims its grants and loans are made on the merits,
yet somehow big-dollar grants keep flowing to companies backed by the
same handful of politically connected venture firms. The Obama
appointees and career staff at Energy and Agriculture do not operate in a
political vacuum; they are well aware who is connected and who isn't.
Such
political investing has resulted in such prominent green taxpayer
failures as solar-panel market Solyndra (awarded a $535 million loan
guarantee), the battery firm A123 (a $249 million grant), and electric
car maker Fisker Automotive (a $529 million loan guarantee). If these
investments are so wonderful, why can't Mr. Khosla and friends invest
their own money and leave taxpayers out of it?
Government
has a role in funding basic research that can't otherwise attract
private capital, but subsidies for commercial ventures lead to
misallocated capital and taxpayer losses. They also increase political
cynicism as taxpayers learn that the subsidies always seem to flow to
the rich and powerful who finance the Democratic Party.
Hello Everybody, My name is Mrs Sharon Sim. I live in singapore and i am a happy woman today? and i told my self that any lender that rescue my family from our poor situation, i will refer any person that is looking for loan to him, he gave me happiness to me and my family, i was in need of a loan of S$250,000.00 to start my life all over as i am a single mother with 3 kids I met this honest and GOD fearing man loan lender that help me with a loan of S$250,000.00 SG. Dollar, he is a GOD fearing man, if you are in need of loan and you will pay back the loan please contact him tell him that is Mrs Sharon, that refer you to him. contact Dr Purva Pius,via email:(urgentloan22@gmail.com)
ReplyDelete